Fannie Mae just had its best quarter in more than a year. On the FNMA board, the argument is about something else entirely: whether Washington ends the conservatorship before the new Congress sits in January.
The third quarter report does not answer that question. What it does show is how much has to happen before a common shareholder sees anything from those profits.
The quarter
Fannie Mae earned $4.2 billion in net income in the third quarter, up from $4.0 billion in the second. Its net worth reached $119.6 billion at the end of September.
The stock traded at $4.12 on Wednesday afternoon, down 1.7% on the day.
Not everything moved the right way. The provision for credit losses rose to $1.14 billion from $485 million a quarter earlier, as the company set aside more for loans that may go bad.
Where the profit goes
Under the terms of Treasury's senior preferred stock, every dollar Fannie Mae adds to its net worth in a quarter is added to Treasury's claim the next quarter. No cash dividend changes hands. The claim simply grows.
That claim, the aggregate liquidation preference, stood at $238.0 billion on 30 September. The filing says it will rise to $241.1 billion by 31 December.
Put plainly, Treasury's claim is about twice the company's entire net worth, and it rises every time Fannie Mae makes money. Treasury also holds a warrant to buy 79.9% of the common stock, on a fully diluted basis, for a nominal price.
The capital gap
Regulators require Fannie Mae to hold far more capital than it has. As of 30 September the company reported a $205 billion shortfall against its risk-based total capital requirement including buffers. Without the buffers, the gap is $128 billion.
The filing says those requirements apply until the conservatorship ends, or later if the regulator orders it.
What the filing says about an exit
Nothing about timing. The report lists the exit from conservatorship among its uncertainties and gives no date, no structure and no plan for how Treasury's claim or warrant would be handled.
That is the gap the board is trying to fill with speculation. Any release has to settle what happens to a $238 billion senior claim and a 79.9% warrant before the common stock is worth what posters hope it is.
Until Treasury and the regulator say how that claim is treated, the quarterly profit belongs to Treasury's line, not to the common.